Cover of Persuasion

Persuasion Study Guide

A-level set textAQA A-level (Lit A)

Notes cover the whole book.

Characters

Themes

  • Persuasion, advice and judgementChapters 2, 4, 7, 10, 11, 12, 16, 17, 21 and 23 · 12 key quotes
  • Rank, vanity and family prideChapters 1, 2, 3, 5, 9, 10, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 19, 20, 21, 22 and 24 · 13 key quotes
  • The navy and self-made menChapters 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 11, 18 and 24 · 6 key quotes
  • Love, regret and constancyChapters 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23 and 24 · 20 key quotes
  • Marriage, money and women's choicesChapters 1, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, 16, 17, 18, 20, 21 and 23 · 7 key quotes
  • Home, family and belongingChapters 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 9, 11, 13, 14, 15, 17, 21, 22 and 24 · 11 key quotes

Chapter summaries

  1. Chapter 1

    The novel opens with Sir Walter Elliot reading his own family's entry in the Baronetage, and the narrator states plainly that vanity is the beginning and end of his character. His late wife was sensible and kept him within his income; since her death thirteen years ago he has run steadily into debt. Her close friend Lady Russell, a widow in Kellynch village, is still a near neighbour and loves Anne, her goddaughter, best of the three daughters. Elizabeth, handsome and twenty-nine, runs the house and hopes to marry soon, still angry that the heir, Mr Elliot, ignored the family's invitations, married a rich woman of lower birth and was reported to have spoken slightingly of the family. Anne, whose looks have faded, counts for nothing with her father and sister, and Elizabeth's idea of economy even includes no longer taking Anne a present. Sir Walter will mortgage but never sell his land, so he and Elizabeth turn to Mr Shepherd and Lady Russell, hoping to save money without giving up anything they enjoy.

  2. Chapter 2

    Mr Shepherd avoids giving unwelcome advice himself and leaves it to Lady Russell, a good and sensible woman who nonetheless has a weakness for rank. She is the only one who thinks to consult Anne, whose suggestions always favour honesty over appearances, and her plan would clear the debts in seven years. Sir Walter rejects it outright and says he would sooner leave Kellynch Hall, an idea Mr Shepherd quickly takes up. Bath is chosen over London, where Mr Shepherd thinks Sir Walter cannot be trusted, and over the small house nearby that Anne wanted, partly because Lady Russell is fond of Bath. Kellynch Hall is to be let, but in secret, since Sir Walter could not bear to be known to be letting it. Lady Russell is also glad the move will separate Elizabeth from Mrs Clay, who has come home to her father with two children after an unprosperous marriage and whom Lady Russell thinks a dangerous companion.

  3. Chapter 3

    Mr Shepherd, backed by his daughter Mrs Clay, argues that the peace will bring rich naval officers looking for homes. Sir Walter objects to the navy on two counts: it raises men of obscure birth to honours, and it ruins a man's looks, as his story of the weather-beaten Admiral Baldwin is meant to show. Anne quietly speaks up for sailors, who have done so much for the country. Admiral Croft, a Somerset man with a fortune, soon applies through Mr Shepherd; Anne knows his rank and record, and she supplies the name of Mrs Croft's brother, Mr Wentworth, when Mr Shepherd cannot remember it. Sir Walter dismisses Mr Wentworth as nobody, but his vanity is soothed that an admiral is a grand enough tenant without ever making a baronet look small. Anne leaves the room with flushed cheeks, and her last words, about a "he" she does not name, show that the news has stirred her deeply.

  4. Chapter 4

    The narrator turns back to the summer of 1806, when Frederick Wentworth, newly made a commander and staying with his brother at Monkford, met the nineteen-year-old Anne. They fell quickly and deeply in love, but Sir Walter thought the match degrading, and Lady Russell feared Wentworth's lack of fortune and his confident, headstrong spirit. Anne gave way to Lady Russell, believing the parting was even more for Wentworth's good than for her own, and he left the country feeling ill used. Since then she has lost her bloom, refused Charles Musgrove, and met no one to compare with Wentworth, who has risen in rank and whom she believes rich from the navy lists and newspapers. At twenty-seven she no longer thinks as she was persuaded to think at nineteen, though she blames neither Lady Russell nor herself. Among Anne's family and friends only her father, Elizabeth and Lady Russell know of the engagement, and Anne hopes to meet the Crofts without awkwardness.

  5. Chapter 5

    The meeting at Kellynch goes smoothly: Sir Walter is flattered into his best behaviour, and Admiral Croft decides the baronet is harmless if not clever. Mary, who often feels unwell, demands Anne's company, and Elizabeth agrees because nobody will want Anne in Bath. Mrs Clay is to go to Bath instead as Elizabeth's helper, which Lady Russell sees as an affront to Anne. Anne fears that Mrs Clay's clever, pleasing manners may draw in Sir Walter, but Elizabeth takes offence at the warning and insists her father would never make a degrading match. At Uppercross Cottage Mary greets Anne with complaints about her health, her husband and the Musgroves, and recovers once Anne cheers her. The Musgroves at the Great House are kind, old-fashioned parents with two lively daughters, Henrietta and Louisa, whose easy affection for each other Anne envies, having known so little of it with her own sisters.

  6. Chapter 6

    Anne learns again that the affairs of Kellynch matter little three miles away, where the Musgroves care more about their own game, horses, music and neighbours. Charles is good-natured and sporting, Mary is quick to feel slighted, and both families bring Anne their complaints about children, servants and precedence, hoping she will put things right. She plays for the young people's dances, though, apart from one short period, no one has really listened to her playing since her mother died. On Michaelmas the Crofts take over Kellynch, and when they call, Mrs Croft's remark about her brother startles Anne until she realises it is Edward, the former curate, who has married. Then Louisa explains that Captain Wentworth is coming, and that he was once captain to the Musgroves' troublesome late son Dick, who served six months on his frigate, the Laconia. The Musgroves' sudden grief for a son they had scarcely missed, and their plan to welcome Wentworth, put Anne's nerves under a new strain.

  7. Chapter 7

    Captain Wentworth's arrival delights the Musgroves, and Anne's first meeting with him is delayed when little Charles dislocates his collarbone in a fall, leaving Anne to manage the whole household's distress. Mary, who says her nerves are not equal to the sickroom, gladly accepts Anne's offer to nurse the boy so that she can dine at the Great House with her husband and meet the captain. When Anne and Wentworth finally meet, it is over in minutes: a bow, a curtsy, and a room full of voices. She tries to reason her feelings away, but finds that eight years mean little to feelings that last. Mary then repeats his remark that Anne was so altered he should not have known her, which mortifies her but also calms her. The narrator moves into Wentworth's mind to show that he has not forgiven her for giving way to persuasion, and that he is ready to marry any pleasing young woman except Anne, though his ideal is still a strong mind with sweetness of manner.

  8. Chapter 8

    Anne and Wentworth are now often in the same company, and though they were once closer than anyone in the room, they are now worse than strangers. He talks easily about naval life, tells how the old sloop Asp might have sunk with him in a gale, and recalls making money in the Laconia alongside his friend Harville, while the Musgrove sisters pore over the Navy List. Mrs Musgrove's sighs for her son Dick bring a flicker of amusement to his face that only Anne notices, before he talks to Mrs Musgrove about her son with real kindness. When he says he would never carry ladies in his ship, Mrs Croft scolds him for talking as if women were fine ladies rather than rational creatures, and calls her years at sea with her husband the happiest part of her life. The evening ends in dancing, with Anne at the instrument and Wentworth admired by every young woman present. His one direct speech to Anne, giving up her seat with studied politeness, hurts her more than anything.

  9. Chapter 9

    Wentworth puts off visiting his brother Edward in Shropshire because Uppercross is so welcoming, and he is soon there almost daily. His presence unsettles Charles Hayter, the well-educated eldest son of the Musgroves' poorer cousins, who is a curate and had seemed attached to Henrietta before Wentworth came. Charles Musgrove thinks Wentworth prefers Louisa and defends his cousin's prospects of the Winthrop estate, while Mary favours Henrietta because she looks down on the Hayters and wants that match ended. Anne cares less about which sister he chooses than that he should know his own mind before he hurts either of them. When Wentworth finds himself almost alone with Anne and the sick little Charles, the awkwardness is broken first by Charles Hayter and then by two-year-old Walter, who clings to Anne's back until Wentworth quietly lifts him away. His silent kindness, and his care to avoid her thanks, leave Anne more agitated than she can bear.

  10. Chapter 10

    Anne judges that Wentworth is not in love with either Musgrove sister, though they admire him, and that Charles Hayter is wise to keep away. On a walk to Winthrop, Louisa makes Henrietta call on the Hayters, and Henrietta comes back reconciled with Charles Hayter. Sitting hidden by the hedgerow, Anne hears Wentworth praise Louisa's decision and firmness, warn that a yielding character can never be relied on, and hold up a hazel nut that has survived the autumn storms as a picture of strength. She then hears Louisa tell him that Charles wanted to marry Anne, who refused him, on Lady Russell's advice as the Musgroves believe. From this Anne sees how Wentworth regards her own character. Yet when he quietly sees to it that she rides home with the Crofts, she understands that though he cannot forgive her, he cannot see her suffer. In the gig the Crofts talk of Frederick choosing one of the girls and recall their own quick courtship.

  11. Chapter 11

    As Anne prepares to leave Uppercross and join Lady Russell at Kellynch, Wentworth returns from visiting his friend Captain Harville at Lyme, and Louisa pushes through a trip there despite her parents' wish to wait till summer. At Lyme the party walk down to the sea and the Cobb and meet Captain and Mrs Harville and Captain Benwick, who lives with them while he mourns his fiancee, Fanny Harville, who died the summer before while he was at sea. Anne privately thinks her own heart no less sorrowful than his, and that he, being younger, will be happy again with another. The Harvilles' warm, open hospitality in their tiny, cleverly fitted house makes Anne think that these would all have been her friends, and Louisa declares sailors to have more worth and warmth than any other men in England. Anne, now used to sitting at the same table as Wentworth, falls into talk with the shy Benwick about poetry and recommends prose to strengthen him against grief. Afterwards she wonders, with some amusement, whether she has preached patience on a point where her own conduct would not bear examination.

  12. Chapter 12

    Henrietta's proposals for Dr Shirley conceal her interest in securing a better curacy for Charles Hayter. A stranger's admiration makes Wentworth look at Anne afresh; the party discovers that he is the Elliot heir. Louisa insists on repeating a jump from the Cobb steps despite Wentworth's warning and falls unconscious. Anne gives practical directions while others panic, and the Harvilles receive Louisa into their home. Wentworth asks Anne to stay as nurse, but Mary's insistence sends Anne home instead. Anne wonders whether the accident exposes limits to the firmness Wentworth admires.

  13. Chapter 13

    Anne makes herself useful to Louisa's parents and helps send their former nursery-maid to Lyme. She encourages the family to join Louisa, then leaves a deserted Uppercross with Lady Russell. Her strongest interests now lie with the people she has met rather than her family's arrangements in Bath. At Kellynch she recognises the Crofts as more deserving occupants than her father. Admiral Croft's removal of the mirrors quietly contrasts his priorities with Sir Walter's. News that Wentworth has asked after her and acknowledged her efforts gives Anne pleasure without resolving her uncertainty about him.

  14. Chapter 14

    Mary and Charles disagree about Benwick, exposing how personal wishes shape their reports of others. Charles thinks Benwick wanted to visit Anne, while Mary denies her sister's appeal. Lady Russell says she will reserve judgement, but soon loses interest when he does not come. Uppercross fills again with children, including the Harvilles', as Louisa improves. The narration compares Mrs Musgrove's pleasure in domestic noise with Lady Russell's enjoyment of Bath's streets. Anne approaches the city without sharing that enthusiasm and learns that Mr Elliot has made repeated visits to Camden Place.

  15. Chapter 15

    Sir Walter and Elizabeth welcome Anne chiefly because they want an audience for their success in Bath. They have accepted Mr Elliot's explanations for his former neglect, supported by Colonel Wallis's favourable account of his marriage. Anne wonders why he is so eager for reconciliation and considers whether he might wish to marry Elizabeth. His arrival confirms that he is the stranger who admired her at Lyme. His conversation and sympathetic questions improve an evening she had expected to find oppressive. The contrast between his attention and her family's indifference helps explain her favourable response without settling the question of his motives.

  16. Chapter 16

    Sir Walter's praise of Mrs Clay strengthens Anne's concern about a possible marriage. Lady Russell finds Mr Elliot's manners and principles highly persuasive, but Anne still questions his renewed interest in the family. The arrival of their titled cousins absorbs Sir Walter and Elizabeth. Anne is embarrassed by the effort they make to secure an acquaintance that offers little intellectual pleasure. Mr Elliot distinguishes socially advantageous company from the lively conversation Anne values. His suggestion that grand acquaintances may distract Sir Walter from Mrs Clay partly reconciles Anne to his argument.

  17. Chapter 17

    Mrs Smith's poverty and restricted movement do not prevent her from taking pleasure in work, conversation and helping poorer neighbours. Her friendship with Nurse Rooke gives her both occupation and news of society. Anne keeps an engagement with her rather than joining the Dalrymples, provoking Sir Walter's contempt for her friend's name and address. Lady Russell sees Mr Elliot's admiration as the foundation of a desirable marriage. The prospect of taking her mother's place at Kellynch briefly moves Anne. Nevertheless, she judges that his polished conduct does not reveal enough of his feelings to justify trust.

  18. Chapter 18

    Mary's letter first complains of the Crofts' neglect and then praises them after their offer to carry it, exposing the dependence of her judgements on personal attention. The engagement of Louisa and Benwick overturns Anne's assumptions about Wentworth. She reasons that shared circumstances and poetry may have drawn the couple together. Her relief is mixed with concern that the friendship between the two captains might have suffered. The Crofts' companionship offers her an attractive picture of marriage. During a walk, the Admiral says Wentworth's letter contains no complaint and proposes inviting him to Bath.

  19. Chapter 19

    Wentworth reaches Bath before the Crofts invite him. His unexpected meeting with Anne shows an embarrassment unlike his earlier apparent composure. Elizabeth refuses to acknowledge him, while he offers Anne the use of his umbrella or a chair. Mr Elliot returns to escort Anne home, and the other women assume an attachment between the cousins. Anne's absorption in Wentworth makes her cousin's conversation difficult to attend to. Her belief that Lady Russell is studying Wentworth proves uncertain when her friend speaks instead of window-curtains, and she resolves to offer him attention at the concert.

  20. Chapter 20

    Anne takes the initiative in greeting Wentworth despite the presence of her father and sister. His comments about Benwick's engagement suggest that he still believes a deep attachment should endure. He also accepts responsibility for giving way to Louisa at Lyme. Anne's pleasure contrasts with Elizabeth's satisfaction in being seen beside titled relations. Mr Elliot arranges to sit beside Anne, flatters her accomplishments and hints that he has long heard her praised. His renewed request for help translating interrupts her conversation with Wentworth, whose abrupt departure makes Anne fear that jealousy will obstruct understanding.

  21. Chapter 21

    Anne visits Mrs Smith and discovers that reports of her supposed engagement have travelled through the Wallises and Nurse Rooke. Once convinced Anne will refuse Mr Elliot, Mrs Smith describes his pursuit of money and his contempt for the family in earlier years. An old letter supports her account. She explains that he now values the baronetcy and fears that Sir Walter might marry Mrs Clay and produce another heir. Anne questions the reliability of information passed through several people before testing it against what she knows. Mr Elliot's refusal to act as executor has also prevented Mrs Smith from pursuing property in the West Indies, making his polished civility inseparable from material harm. Mrs Smith explains her earlier praise as deference to a presumed marriage, while her request for help reveals a personal interest in Anne's influence.

  22. Chapter 22

    Anne's new knowledge makes Mr Elliot's attentions repellent, though she tries to avoid an open confrontation. Charles and Mary arrive with news of the preparations for Henrietta's and Louisa's marriages. Their party draws Anne to the White Hart before she can confide in Lady Russell. Mary's discovery of Mr Elliot talking to Mrs Clay contradicts the expected timing of his departure and leaves their relationship uncertain. A debate over a theatre visit allows Anne to state that she would prefer the Musgroves' company to her family's party. Elizabeth's invitation to Wentworth pleases Mary but embarrasses Anne, who recognises his contempt for its belated social calculation.

  23. Chapter 23

    Conversation about engagements makes Anne and Wentworth conscious of their own history. Harville's grief over Benwick's changed attachment leads him and Anne into a debate about constancy. Anne challenges literary evidence written largely by men and describes the confinement that gives women fewer distractions from feeling. Wentworth hears her and writes a declaration that resolves their uncertainty. Alone together on a walk, they renew their promises and explain their recent misunderstandings. He acknowledges resentment and pride, while Anne defends her younger self's duty to Lady Russell without endorsing that advice for others.

  24. Chapter 24

    Wentworth's fortune and standing make the match acceptable to Sir Walter, whose values remain centred on appearance and rank. Lady Russell accepts that she misjudged both Wentworth and Mr Elliot and attaches herself to Anne's husband. Mary's pleasure in the marriage is mixed with continued social comparison. Mr Elliot's arrangement with Mrs Clay removes her from Sir Walter but leaves their own future uncertain. Wentworth's practical help to Mrs Smith contrasts with Mr Elliot's refusal to assist her. Anne's happiness includes a new family of naval connections, though the closing prospect of war leaves a real source of anxiety.

Key quotes

Vanity was the beginning and the end of Sir Walter Elliot's character; vanity of person and of situation.
Chapter 1

The narrator sums up Sir Walter in one blunt sentence: he is proud of both his looks and his rank, and there is little else to him.

Rank, vanity and family pride

her word had no weight, her convenience was always to give way—she was only Anne.
Chapter 1

The heroine is introduced as the overlooked daughter. The short final phrase shows how little her father and Elizabeth value her, though the narrator makes clear that anyone of real understanding would value her highly.

Home, family and belonging

He had condescended to mortgage as far as he had the power, but he would never condescend to sell. No; he would never disgrace his name so far.
Chapter 1

Sir Walter will borrow against his land but not sell it, because selling would hurt his pride. The irony is that his spending, not any sale, is what threatens the family.

Rank, vanity and family pride

Every emendation of Anne's had been on the side of honesty against importance.
Chapter 2

Anne's values are the reverse of her father's: she cares about paying what is owed, not about keeping up appearances.

Rank, vanity and family pridePersuasion, advice and judgement

though a great deal is due to the feelings of the gentleman, and the head of a house, like your father, there is still more due to the character of an honest man.
Chapter 2

Lady Russell, speaking to Anne over her plan, puts an honest man's duty to pay his debts above a gentleman's feelings. It is the principle Anne wants her father to follow, but Sir Walter will not hear of it.

Persuasion, advice and judgementRank, vanity and family pride

But the usual fate of Anne attended her, in having something very opposite from her inclination fixed on.
Chapter 2

Anne's wishes are set aside as a matter of course. The dry phrase "the usual fate of Anne" shows how often this happens.

Home, family and belonging

First, as being the means of bringing persons of obscure birth into undue distinction, and raising men to honours which their fathers and grandfathers never dreamt of; and secondly, as it cuts up a man's youth and vigour most horribly
Chapter 3

Sir Walter's two objections to the navy are birth and looks, which are exactly the two things he values most in himself. He resents men rising above the rank they were born to.

The navy and self-made menRank, vanity and family pride

The navy, I think, who have done so much for us, have at least an equal claim with any other set of men, for all the comforts and all the privileges which any home can give.
Chapter 3

Anne's rare words in company defend the sailors her father mocks, and they show where her sympathies lie.

The navy and self-made men

A few months more, and he, perhaps, may be walking here.
Chapter 3

The chapter ends on a mystery: Anne is stirred by the thought of a man she does not name, just after the name Wentworth has come up.

Love, regret and constancy

She was persuaded to believe the engagement a wrong thing: indiscreet, improper, hardly capable of success, and not deserving it.
Chapter 4

The word "persuaded" names the novel's central idea. Anne was not ordered to give Wentworth up; Lady Russell's steady, loving advice talked her into believing the engagement wrong.

Persuasion, advice and judgementMarriage, money and women's choices

No one had ever come within the Kellynch circle, who could bear a comparison with Frederick Wentworth, as he stood in her memory.
Chapter 4

Eight years on, Anne's feelings have not been replaced. Her narrow life at Kellynch has given her no chance to move on.

Love, regret and constancy

She had been forced into prudence in her youth, she learned romance as she grew older: the natural sequel of an unnatural beginning.
Chapter 4

Anne has reversed the usual pattern of youthful romance giving way to caution. The sentence sets out her mature view that caution can be the greater mistake.

Persuasion, advice and judgementLove, regret and constancy

Then I am sure Anne had better stay, for nobody will want her in Bath.
Chapter 5

Elizabeth's careless reply shows how little Anne matters to her own sister, and she says it as a plain fact.

Home, family and belonging

To be claimed as a good, though in an improper style, is at least better than being rejected as no good at all
Chapter 5

Anne takes what comfort she can from being needed, even by a sister who claims her selfishly. The line sums up her place in the family.

Home, family and belonging

The Baronet will never set the Thames on fire, but there seems no harm in him.
Chapter 5

The Admiral's plain, good-humoured verdict cuts Sir Walter down to size, and it contrasts with Sir Walter's own judgement of men by looks.

The navy and self-made menRank, vanity and family pride

another lesson, in the art of knowing our own nothingness beyond our own circle, was become necessary for her
Chapter 6

Anne sees that the Elliots' great concerns mean almost nothing to their neighbours. Austen gently mocks the self-importance of every small society.

Home, family and belongingRank, vanity and family pride

Anne hoped she had outlived the age of blushing; but the age of emotion she certainly had not.
Chapter 6

Anne's calm surface hides strong feeling. A single mention of Mrs Croft's brother is enough to shake her.

Love, regret and constancy

a fine dashing felow, only two perticular about the schoolmaster
Chapter 6

Dick's badly spelt praise gives a comic but warm picture of Captain Wentworth as a commander who took trouble even over a careless young midshipman.

The navy and self-made men

Alas! with all her reasoning, she found, that to retentive feelings eight years may be little more than nothing.
Chapter 7

Anne tries to argue herself out of her feelings, but the narrator shows that time has not touched them. Her love is lasting, not a passing mood.

Love, regret and constancy

So altered that he should not have known her again!
Chapter 7

Wentworth's words, passed on by Mary, wound Anne because they contrast her altered appearance with his. She tries to use their sobering effect to regain composure.

Love, regret and constancy

He had not forgiven Anne Elliot. She had used him ill, deserted and disappointed him; and worse, she had shown a feebleness of character in doing so, which his own decided, confident temper could not endure.
Chapter 7

We now see the broken engagement from Wentworth's side. He blames Anne less for leaving him than for being persuaded, which he sees as weakness.

Persuasion, advice and judgementLove, regret and constancy

Now they were as strangers; nay, worse than strangers, for they could never become acquainted. It was a perpetual estrangement.
Chapter 8

Two people who once knew each other best are now forced into polite distance. The repetition of "strangers" stresses how complete the loss is.

Love, regret and constancy

But I hate to hear you talking so like a fine gentleman, and as if women were all fine ladies, instead of rational creatures. We none of us expect to be in smooth water all our days.
Chapter 8

Mrs Croft argues that women are sensible equals who can share a sailor's life. Her marriage, spent at sea with her husband, is presented as a true partnership.

Marriage, money and women's choicesThe navy and self-made men

His cold politeness, his ceremonious grace, were worse than anything.
Chapter 8

Wentworth's perfect manners towards Anne are a way of keeping her at a distance, and she finds them more painful than open coldness.

Love, regret and constancy

And, pray, who is Charles Hayter? Nothing but a country curate. A most improper match for Miss Musgrove of Uppercross.
Chapter 9

Mary judges a man by his family's standing, as her father would, and her objection is really about her own dignity. It shows the Elliot pride at work in her.

Rank, vanity and family prideMarriage, money and women's choices

whenever Winthrop comes into his hands, he will make a different sort of place of it, and live in a very different sort of way; and with that property, he will never be a contemptible man
Chapter 9

Charles Musgrove answers Mary in terms of land and inheritance. Both arguments make property and position central to assessing the match.

Marriage, money and women's choicesRank, vanity and family pride

he was resolutely borne away, before she knew that Captain Wentworth had done it.
Chapter 9

Wentworth helps Anne without a word, then avoids her thanks. The small act of kindness throws her into confusion because it shows he still notices her.

Love, regret and constancy

If I loved a man, as she loves the Admiral, I would always be with him, nothing should ever separate us, and I would rather be overturned by him, than driven safely by anybody else.
Chapter 10

Louisa's romantic speech wins Wentworth's approval. She admires the Crofts' marriage for its togetherness and sees boldness as a virtue in itself.

Marriage, money and women's choicesLove, regret and constancy

It is the worst evil of too yielding and indecisive a character, that no influence over it can be depended on.
Chapter 10

Wentworth's praise of firmness is spoken to Louisa, but Anne, listening unseen, knows how it applies to her own yielding to Lady Russell. It sets out his view of persuasion as weakness.

Persuasion, advice and judgement

He could not forgive her, but he could not be unfeeling.
Chapter 10

Anne reads his small act of care in sending her home with the Crofts. The balanced sentence holds both his resentment and his kindness.

Love, regret and constancy

These would have been all my friends
Chapter 11

The Harvilles' warmth shows Anne the life she gave up eight years ago. The simple thought carries her regret without self-pity.

The navy and self-made menLove, regret and constancyHome, family and belonging

He is younger than I am; younger in feeling, if not in fact; younger as a man. He will rally again, and be happy with another.
Chapter 11

Anne compares Benwick's grief with her own long loss and expects him to recover. Her belief that a man's feelings mend sooner than her own sets up the question of constancy.

Love, regret and constancy

she had been eloquent on a point in which her own conduct would ill bear examination.
Chapter 11

Anne sees the irony of advising Benwick to struggle against grief when she has not got over her own. Austen gives her self-knowledge and a sense of humour about herself.

Love, regret and constancyPersuasion, advice and judgement

Both seemed to look to her for directions.
Chapter 12

The emergency makes Anne's judgement a source of authority to men who cannot decide what to do.

Persuasion, advice and judgement

Kellynch Hall had passed into better hands than its owners’.
Chapter 13

Anne separates the moral responsibility of running a home from the inherited right to own it.

Rank, vanity and family prideHome, family and belonging

Everybody has their taste in noises as well as in other matters;
Chapter 14

The narrator's comparison questions the assumption that one social group's pleasures are naturally superior to another's.

Rank, vanity and family prideHome, family and belonging

They had no inclination to listen to her.
Chapter 15

The family welcomes Anne as a listener while giving little attention to her own experience.

Home, family and belonging

She had hoped better things from their high ideas of their own situation in life, and was reduced to form a wish which she had never foreseen; a wish that they had more pride;
Chapter 16

The irony turns pride against itself: Anne wants self-respect rather than her family's eagerness to court superior rank.

Rank, vanity and family pride

Mr. Elliot was rational, discreet, polished, but he was not open.
Chapter 17

Anne separates social accomplishment from the emotional candour she needs before she can trust someone.

Persuasion, advice and judgementMarriage, money and women's choices

He had an affectionate heart. He must love somebody.
Chapter 18

Anne understands Benwick's new attachment through his capacity and need for affection, rather than simply condemning his change.

Love, regret and constancy

one half of her should not be always so much wiser than the other half, or always suspecting the other of being worse than it was.
Chapter 19

The narration presents Anne's inward debate with humour, allowing desire to challenge her habit of self-surveillance.

Love, regret and constancyPersuasion, advice and judgement

He ought not; he does not.
Chapter 20

Wentworth's shift from moral expectation to certainty makes his account of enduring love sound intensely personal.

Love, regret and constancy

Facts shall speak.
Chapter 21

Mrs Smith turns from denunciation to evidence, while Anne continues to distinguish documentary proof from reported conversation.

Persuasion, advice and judgement

It was a struggle between propriety and vanity; but vanity got the better, and then Elizabeth was happy again.
Chapter 22

The narrator exposes the self-interest beneath Elizabeth's apparently considerate decision to offer an evening invitation instead of dinner.

Rank, vanity and family prideHome, family and belonging

Men have had every advantage of us in telling their own story.
Chapter 23

Anne questions whose experience becomes literary authority, making the debate about constancy also a debate about access to expression.

Love, regret and constancyMarriage, money and women's choices

I can listen no longer in silence.
Chapter 23

The letter transforms overheard conversation into an act of direct communication and ends the lovers' prolonged uncertainty.

Love, regret and constancy

She loved Anne better than she loved her own abilities;
Chapter 24

Lady Russell's love allows correction of her judgement, distinguishing her from characters whose vanity prevents change.

Persuasion, advice and judgementHome, family and belonging

Talking points

These questions cover the whole novel, including its ending. Use the suggested chapters to compare the language, choices and relationships behind each argument.

  1. When does persuasion become a form of care, and when does it prevent someone from judging for themselves?

    Compare Lady Russell's advice about the first engagement with Anne's account of duty after the reunion. Consider what each person knows when making a decision.

    Look again at: Chapter 4, Chapter 23, Chapter 24

  2. How does the novel distinguish firmness of principle from stubbornness?

    Follow the discussion of the hazel nut, Louisa's insistence on the Cobb and Wentworth's later account of what he learnt at Lyme.

    Look again at: Chapter 10, Chapter 12, Chapter 23

  3. What makes a home valuable in this novel?

    Compare Sir Walter's attachment to Kellynch, the Crofts' alterations and the Harvilles' small house. Attend to the uses people make of space.

    Look again at: Chapter 1, Chapter 11, Chapter 13

  4. How far does the novel invite readers to trust Anne's interpretations?

    Compare her reading of Wentworth's small kindnesses with her uncertainty about Lady Russell in the street and the explanations offered during the reunion.

    Look again at: Chapter 9, Chapter 10, Chapter 19, Chapter 23

  5. What kinds of knowledge can the social world of Bath provide or conceal?

    Set the Dalrymples' social value beside Nurse Rooke's information and the letters Mrs Smith produces. Ask how Anne tests different kinds of evidence.

    Look again at: Chapter 16, Chapter 17, Chapter 21

  6. How does the novel explore differences between men's and women's opportunities to recover from loss?

    Read Anne's comparison of herself with Benwick alongside the debate with Harville. Consider both everyday occupation and authority over written accounts.

    Look again at: Chapter 11, Chapter 18, Chapter 23

  7. What work does comedy do in the portrayal of family relationships?

    Look at competing complaints at Uppercross, Mary's changing judgement of the Crofts and the family's response to Anne's marriage. Consider the distance between what characters say and what readers can infer.

    Look again at: Chapter 6, Chapter 18, Chapter 24

  8. What does the ending resolve, and what sources of uncertainty does it leave?

    Compare Lady Russell's capacity to revise her opinions, Mr Elliot's arrangement with Mrs Clay and the closing prospect of naval war. Consider how these qualify the marriage's happiness.

    Look again at: Chapter 23, Chapter 24